MasterChef – May 11 – Marco’s pub challenge

It’s Wed night and it’s still Marco week on MasterChef. Yippee!
TV blurb says: This challenge is all about the pub lunch. The contestants are split into two teams and must cook three courses for 70 people with Marco Pierre White running the pass.

So, expect lots of “Yes, Marco!”, undercooked fish and tears.

Here we are at the first service challenge of the season: a pub challenge. Luckily Brett’s food dream is to run a gastro pub in the country. Thank god they reminded us he’s an airline captain, otherwise I would have thought he was a member of the crew who’d accidentally wandered into camera view.

Pony tail brunette Nicolette – not to be confused with swishy pony tail brunette Zoe volunteers to captain the blue, while Brett is keen to lead red.

Nicolette finally gets camera time.

Nicolette finally gets camera time.

The captains have to lucky dip for the type of dish. For entree Nicolette gets something crumbed; Brett something skewered. Main for Nicolette is surf, so Brett gets, you guessed it, turf. And dessert is cold and hot.
They have to serve 70 people, so 210 plates, which is a lot.
They cram into the pub kitchen and Brett’s team is quick to pick dishes, guided by Captain captain, while the blues are just a mess, yelling out ideas. On red, Elise and a mystery girl have to peel 240 jumbo prawns, so they got the short straw there. Red’s main will be sirloin steak with jus, so MPW drifts by with the astonishing advice to put a wet dishcloth under a chopping board to stop it slipping. Give that man another Michelin star!
Finally blues decide to do a panko prawn – which Cecilia had suggested yonks ago but her voice was lost in the din – but blue has nabbed all the prawns. You snooze, you lose, reds. Instead they’re doing crumbed scallop with corn puree. Main will be crispy king fish with roast spuds and a beurre blanc and dessert is another bloody panna cotta.

MPW is not happy with blue Nicolette’s idea to serve only three scallops: “Generosity is the greatest garnish in the world.” Quick – print that on a T-shirt.
Brett tells red underlings Jimmy the Brother and Nidhi to remove all the fat from the sirloin – this is going to lead to trouble.
On blue, they’re prepping the kingfish and MPW is not impressed with Intense Matt’s pinboning efforts. He fishes out a bone: “That’s big enough to choke a donkey.”
Reds seem to have it together, being efficient while having fun in the kitchen. Olivia (well, I think it’s Olivia – MasterChef really needs to make them wear aprons with emboidered names), Carmen and Charlie are on dessert, making a warm brownie.
On red, Heather – nice to meet you – is in charge of the jus for the steak but MPW says, while it taste great, she needs heaps more. Heather is dying inside but trying not to show her fear in front of MPW. She has enough for one tablespoon per person. That’s not much jus for a steak.

Service starts
After a quick pep talk from Marco, the yelling begins as he mans the pass. Did anyone else here him say: “Be the wolf pack – work as a team.” What is this – a Hangover movie?
The red team’s massive prawns on skewers look amazing but poor Jimmy is freaking out at the grill as MPW barks orders at him. Blue’s scallops could do with a scatter of micro herbs.
The judges: They like the charry look of the prawns and Gaz gives the thumbs up as the happy music plays: “They’ve done a smashing job.” Matt loves the remoulade and that the dishes look consistent.
The blue team’s scallop cookers are having trouble keeping up with Dementor shrieking orders at them and Ranger Miles concedes some could be a bit under or overcooked.
The judges: George thinks four scallops is still not enough for a pub meal and they are overcooked. Matt says reds won the entree round.

Main courses
Captain my captain Brett is in charge of grilling the steaks, while on the other team Harry is doing the kingfish and he’s flustered because people seem to think it takes 10 seconds to cook crispy-skinned fish. MPW is barking away like a mad dog at the pass.
Blue Con – keen to redeem himself – has pretty much taken charge of the dessert. He thinks it’s a bit sweet so is whipping up a lime gel to add acidity.

The judges: Immediately comment on the paucity of jus with the sirloin and George is devastated they’ve removed all the fat. (Jimmy was right but he followed captain’s orders.)
Meanwhile, there’s a crisis in the blue team, with not enough fish to fulfil the orders. Surely they counted the portions earlier? What was that challenge last year where a team came up short of dishes in the dessert round because someone put a tray of something on top of a fridge, then no one realised it was there – except the chortling camera operator. Perhaps this is one of those moments where MPW plucks a number out of the air to put the wind up them for not doing extras.
He tears into the kitchen screaming poor Harry’s name, and Harry’s defence that he allowed for extra portions is brushed aside as MPW interrogates each member of the team in case they’ve stuffed a fillet down their pants as a lark.
“They just swam off, did they?” MPW asks. Luckily Ranger Miles dives into the pantry and finds a stray fish which Harry can then fillet, resisting the temptation to slap MPW in the face with it instead.
The judges: Love the fish and declare it the winner of the round.

Dessert time
The brownie leader (I think Marco called her Chloe) is confident in her baking – even as she quakes before MPW’s steely gaze – while Con is also happy with his panna cotta.

The judges: It’s a choc brownie with a walnut caramel sauce and Gaz is in heaven. It’s moist and fudgy. Gaz thinks it would be a best seller if it was a regular on the menu. Well done, Chloe.

Con’s panna cottas with pineapple, sago and ginger crumbs are nice and wobbly and it’s a more modern-looking dessert than the brownie.

George thinks it’s elegant and Matt loves the contrasting textures.
So, the judges think dessert will decide the winner, but both are good. I’m wondering if the brownie will get the edge, as it’s more pub like?

Time for feedback
MPW tells them how wonderfully they did, they performed better than some professionals, yadda yadda. As we already know, prawns get the thumbs up, scallops sucked; steak is a no, kingfish yes.
Reds get high praise for the brownie while Matt drools over the panna cotta, saying it’s his dish of the day. Just as they get their hopes up Gaz butts in to say the prawns were his and Georgie’s dish of the day, so reds win.
Perhaps next year there should be a judges’ save (like the Tim Gunn save on Project Runway), where each judge gets to save a contestant who’s on the losing team but has done really well, such as Con with his panna cotta tonight.
Apologies to those contestants whose names I mixed up – I was watching live and couldn’t pause anything to cross check. If some of you could shave your heads or wear weird earrings like the boys do, I would appreciate it.

Tomorrow night: It’s the pick a letter, name the ingredient challenge. This should be fun to play along with at home. Will Z be anything other than zucchini?



  1. Marco gets stressed out over a piece of kingfish.

    Simplicity.Dreams .Fear.

    Y’ know when I was a boy in Yorkshire….

  2. Blue team looked like they were in trouble right from the start…. does that mean they win????

  3. The case of the missing fish๐ŸŸ๐Ÿ ๐Ÿก….probably the fish he started to cook during entree

    • Yep. Bet he was annoyed that he was right about getting the fish started early, and Marco stopped him, then yelled at him for the fish not cooking fast enough.

  4. The food from both teams may be on par but Marco will said the red team worked better in the kitchen. Red team will win

  5. Three big prawns~ Gary, George and Jowl$y.

    The Pub With No Fear.

    “Drizzle”~ Is it raining in there?

  6. I predict the guy who put white pepper on the roasting pumpkin will go home.
    It seems to be a crime against cooking. Who knew?

      • I was taught white pepper in white sauces, it would be ok on pumpkin, but what a look marco gave him๐Ÿ˜ 

      • Until about 1960 white pepper was standard in Australia on everything. Black pepper was a new and exotic introduction like capsicum, zucchini and a whole lot of other stuff.

    • I use it because it can’t be seen. Like in mashed potato So it seems logical to use it on roasting potato.

  7. 4 scallops for entree and the glutton judges complained the serve is too small.

    A small square of brownie and the judges said it is a generous serve.

  8. Smiling and shaking at the same time. An amata at the peak of their powers, multi-tasking..

    Marco’s bringing the sarcasm tonight.

  9. I haven’t read anything yet, may be repeating things already said. But dammit, I’m calling for hairnets all around, including Marco’s head. Most of the women seem to have waist length hair and all the long ponytails swinging so close to the food is grossing me out. Keep your damn hair under control in the kitchen, no one cares if you look cute or not. Blondie dude is the same, hair swinging in front of his face. You know he will push it back with his hand.

    Who was the git who said “Hopefully Marco will steer us right.”? Does he think Marco Pierre White is there to sabotage them?

    Blue team takes 40 minutes to plan their menu, then stand around for ages with their fingers up their butts when they find out all the prawns are gone. Un-fucking-believable.

    • I did a food handling course & none of these should ever set foot in any kitchen. Hair should be tied back & in hair nets. No jewellery. Food should be kept at a certain temperature or bacteria get in it. They break all the rules.

  10. ‘I like my Jew .. my Jew is delicious .. not enough Jew ..’
    I don’t think Heather did French at school, but there’s a queue of Hasidics outside her door.

    How can 3 prawns on a skewer be considered heartier than 4 scallops?
    The brownie, as delicious as I’m sure it was, is just something you’d see at a school fete – Con’s effort was more intricate and professional.
    I notice The Siblings were on the same team – the umbilical cord remains intact.
    I guess the blue team did fluff around a lot, and Marco enjoyed flirting with the gals from the reds. You can take the guy out of Italy, but …

    The guest chef from the previous night was really good-looking in a spooky kind of way. As oppose to his carpaccio, which was just spooky.

    • Agree, brownie’s are pretty ordinary. That’s something I’d pack in school lunches, not serve as a sophisticated dessert in a restaurant.

      • Didn’t get the big deal over the 4 scallops. No big difference between that and 3 prawns. AND this was just an entree.
        Brownies…maybe they were delicious but as per some MKR contestants, not a competition dish.

        • Plating the scallops in their shells would have given the perception of a “larger” serving. The prawns did appear to be a decent size but I agree, entree is entree unless you’re in USA where an appetizer comes first followed by an entree?

    • Lulu, I’m thinking he has a very neat apartment, dresses only in black and has a collection of samurai swords.

      • Yes, he did seem very zen. I’m fascinated.
        But what is it with chefs and tattoos? Is it compulsory?

  11. Did any one notice the dirty nails on the guest chef from the other night. Yuk it put me off more than the red meat.

  12. Thanks for the great recap Juz.
    Well pub meals have changed a lot. I remember when they were pretty simplke fare not like the lar di dar stuff they serve these days. They used to be a cheap meal. Not any more.
    Ha ha, that was hilarious when that team went to get the prawns & there were none. I thought when the other team took them all, bad luck if the other team want to use prawns.
    So what happened to that fish? The guy said he counted them & had enough but they disappeared. It was odd. Smart arse Marco asked if they swam away.

    • If I’m at a pub I usually get a schnitty, because it’s comfort food I would never make at home. Scallops to me are for a ritzy night out.

  13. I thought the other day was the worst immunity challenge evah but now I am starting to think this is the worst season evah.

    • This season wants it real bad to be the worst evah It’ll be right down to the wire.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *